Go Back   Steve's Digicams Forums >

LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old May 29, 2006, 4:24 PM   #1
Junior Member
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 1

Hi folks, this is my first post. I just received my 7D with 28-75 2.8 from Adorama (great deal at $900), and Tamron 28-300 walkaround ($150 at Cord). Thank you for your excellent posts, especially JimC. Years ago I was an avid amateur, 7xi, 50 1.7, 28-80 and 100-300 xi zooms. I'm looking forward to the digital learning experience.

I'm a former scientist so I decided to do a semi-scientific comparison of Minolta v Canon v Nikon lenses. I don't know if all this info has been posted before, but I'll give you my novice opinion and you can let me know if I'm way off. I choose the following lenses because I own them or want them, so this is not comprehensive. I compared similar lenses at Photodo, using identical or similar focal lengths and specs. I looked for the most recent new prices, and I realize some Minoltas my not be available (but Sony should be similar in quality and price). If available, I used IS/anti-shake lenses for Canon and Nikon. Remember, I couldn't always compare apples to apples, I got as close as I could (such as the Nikon 60 macro v Minolta 50).

In almost all available comparisons the quality of the lenses, using the overall grade, were extremely close (within 10%). Let me repeat that, assuming Photodo does a good job with a good lens, the quality grades were all very close. No one company is clearly superior. However, the prices often varied more than 10% between lowest and highest. So, I picked out the best and worst "value" in each lens class. The results, best value listed first, worst value listed second (Canon=C, Minolta=M, Nikon=N):

50 1.7 M and C N (Nikon 37% more)

85 1.4 CN (Canon 85 1.8 great value, Nikon 300% more!)

50 2.8 macro C N (Minolta was close, Nikon 65% more)

100 2.8 macro C N (Again, Minolta was close, Nikon 76% more)

17-35 D + G M C (Canon 51% more)

Not a very clean comparison - D type prices with G type tests - due to lack of info.

28-75 G M N (no D type test info, Nikon 36% more))

70-200 G equal equal

So, here's what I learned: Nikon is way overpriced, overall Minolta is the best value, there are plenty of lens choices at all lengths for anyone but the most demanding pro, Minolta/Sony could use a good 17-55, Minolta seems to have more lower price value lenses such as the 28-75 D and the used beercan, only Minolta has the 500 8.0 a unique value.

Remember, all my opinions are uninformed, I'm a newbie. Mostly, I'm trying to post info for others like me who are trying to decide whether to stick with Minolta. I realize I'm preaching to the choir on this forum, but let me know what you think. Also, is there an accurate website for all or most used lens prices so I can do a similar comparison.

I'm off to our local military cemetery for a remembrance ceremony and some shots.
bctr is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old May 29, 2006, 8:24 PM   #2
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 143

My Minolta 5D is my first SLR of any kind ever as photography is a fairly new hobby for me. One of the reasons I chose Minolta over Canon or Nikon was it seemed that the glass was cheaper (but not of less quality). I have two great oldlenses and between them both didn't even pay $250 (the beercan and the old 28-135) and both are in very good condition. And both lenses were purchased in a camera store within the last 5 months! To get that kind of optical quality in either C or N would have cost much more unless you stumble upon an amazing Ebay deal or find one in a pawn shop. Add Anti Shake to those lenses and it's an incredible bang-for-the-buck that you can't touch with any other brand.
gipper51 is offline   Reply With Quote

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 9:40 PM.