S5200 vs IS 2S

[Jayzoom]

My apologies for adding another S5200 vs S2 IS topic but I'm about to hit the buy button and I'm not sure which one to get. Until yesterday evening I was planning on getting the S5200 but then my friend hauled out some pictures that she took with her S2 IS that looked so good that I'm rethinking my decision.

Here are options that I'm trying to choose between:

FujiFilm S5200 $255 with 1GB H-Type XD memory $40 total $295
Canon S2 IS $299 with 256 SD card that I already own $299

Which choice would you guys make?

Thank you!
Jay